Please note: this meeting's minutes have not been finalized yet. Actions taken on legislation and their results are not available.

Meeting Details

Meeting Name: Budget, Finance and Audit Standing Committee Agenda status: Final
Meeting date/time: 9/21/2016 1:00 PM Minutes status: Draft  
Meeting location: Committee of the Whole
Published agenda: Agenda Agenda Published minutes: Not available  
Meeting video:  
Attachments:
File #Ver.Agenda #NameTypeTitleActionResultAction Details
15-4049 1  ContractStatus of Finance Department/Purchasing Division Contract 6000238 - 100% City Funding - To Provide Comprehensive Annual Financial Reports for 2016, 2017 and 2018 - Contractor: Plante & Moran PLLC, Location: 1098 Woodward Avenue, Detroit, MI. 48226 - Contract Period: Upon FRC Approval through June 30, 2019 - Total Contract Amount: $5,650,000.00. OFFICE OF THE AUDITOR GENERAL (CONTRACT HELD BY COUNCIL PRESIDENT BRENDA JONES DURING THE RECESS PROCEDURE OF AUGUST 16, 2016) (BROUGHT BACK AS DIRECTED ON 9-7-16)   Not available
15-4050 1  Communication or ReportStatus of Legislative Policy Division submitting report relative to Detailed Financial Analysis of the City of Detroit’s FY 2015 General Fund and Government Wide Financial Statements. (The Legislative Policy Division (LPD) in this report provides the City Council with a detailed financial analysis of the City’s FY 2015 General fund and Government Wide financial statements. We analyzed the General Fund’s Unassigned Surplus, Balance Sheet and Revenues and Expenditures. Also, the Legislative Policy Division analyzed in detail the Government Wide Primary Government’s Statement of Net Position and Statement of Activities. The Legislative Policy Division also provide the statements for FY 2014 and FY 2013 for comparison. The FY 2013 statements show the City before the bankruptcy. The FY 2014 statements show the City in bankruptcy. The FY 2015 statements show the City after bankruptcy.) (BROUGHT BACK AS DIRECTED ON 9-7-16)   Not available
15-4051 1  Communication or ReportStatus of Legislative Policy Division submitting report relative to Popular Annual Financial Report (PAFR) for FY 2015. (The purpose of this report is to present a Popular Annual Financial Report (PAFR) for FY 2015 using data from the City’s Comprehensive Annual Financial Report as of June 30, 2015 (2015 CAFR) for the Duggan Administration to consider producing on an annual basis to enable citizens and other interested parties to read an “executive summary” style document giving a general overview of the City of Detroit’s financial condition.) (BROUGHT BACK AS DIRECTED ON 9-7-16)   Not available
15-4052 1  Communication or ReportStatus of Legislative Policy Division submitting report relative to Benchmark Comparison of the City of Detroit’s 2015 Comprehensive Annual Financial Report (CAFR) with other cities. (BROUGHT BACK AS DIRECTED ON 9-7-16)   Not available
15-4053 1  Communication or ReportStatus of Legislative Policy Division submitting report relative to Review of the 2015 Comprehensive Annual Financial Report (CAFR) for the City of Detroit. (BROUGHT BACK AS DIRECTED ON 9-7-16)   Not available
15-4054 1  Communication or ReportStatus of Council Member Mary Sheffield submitting memorandum relative to Request for the Legislative Policy Division to provide draft resolution amending the Special Assessment District Ordinance to Require 70% approval. (BROUGHT BACK AS DIRECTED ON 9-7-16)   Not available
15-4055 1  Communication or ReportStatus of Council President Brenda Jones submitting memorandum relative to Demolition Audit Update. (BROUGHT BACK AS DIRECTED ON 9-7-16)   Not available
15-4056 1  ContractStatus of Finance Department/Purchasing Division Contract No. 6000152 - 100% City Funding - To Provide Assessor Services - Contractor: Wayne County, Location: 2 Woodward Avenue, Suite 824, Detroit, MI 48226 - Contract Period: Upon City Council Approval through June 30, 2017 - Total Contract Amount: $85,000.00. OCFO - OFFICE OF THE ASSESSOR (BROUGHT BACK AS DIRECTED ON 9-7-16)   Not available
15-4057 1  ContractStatus of Finance Department/Purchasing Division Contract No. 6000060 - 100% City Funding - To Provide a Lease Agreement for the Finance Department - Contractor: Cadillac Tower MI LLC, Location: 2 Woodward Avenue, Suite 1200, Detroit, MI 48226 - Contract Period: October 17, 2016 through February 28, 2017 - Total Contract Amount: $193,978.43. OCFO - OFFICE OF THE CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER (BROUGHT BACK AS DIRECTED ON 9-7-16)   Not available
15-4058 1  ResolutionStatus of City Clerk’s Office/Finance Department-Board of Assessors submitting reso. autho. Application for 143 Homestead Neighborhood Enterprise Zone Certificates for Various NEZ-H Approved Areas within Phase 1 and Phase II List #2016 - 01. (The City Clerk’s Office and the Finance Department Assessment Division RECOMMEND APPROVAL of this petition.) (BROUGHT BACK AS DIRECTED ON 9-7-16)   Not available
15-4059 1  ResolutionStatus of City Clerk’s Office/Finance Department-Board of Assessors submitting reso. autho. Application for 23 Homestead Neighborhood Enterprise Zone Certificates for Various NEZ-H Approved Areas within Phase 1 and Phase II List #2016 - 02. (The City Clerk’s Office and the Finance Department Assessment Division RECOMMEND APPROVAL of this petition.) (BROUGHT BACK AS DIRECTED ON 9-7-16)   Not available
15-4060 1  OrdinanceStatus of Legislative Policy Division submitting report relative to Amending the Special Assessment Districts (SAD) Ordinance to require 70% approval of resident homeowners to establish SAD. (The Legislative Policy Division’s preliminary review of the existing applicable law indicates that, in the event that a majority of City Council desires to make this change, it should be within Council’s authority to do so. However, the Legislative Policy Division requests that this report be referred to Corporation Counsel for their official opinion on this legal point.) (BROUGHT BACK AS DIRECTED ON 9-7-16)   Not available
15-4061 1  Communication or ReportStatus of Legislative Policy Division submitting report relative to Detroit VEBA’s FY 2015 Audit Reports. (As noted in the Legislative Policy Division’s report on the Voluntary Employee Beneficiary Association, the audit confirmed that the market value of the bonds issued by the City to the VEBAs were approximately 45% of their face (par) value. This was not sufficient to provide the retirees with the minimal benefits that were promised to them per the Plan of Adjustment.) (BROUGHT BACK AS DIRECTED ON 9-7-16)   Not available
15-4062 1  Communication or ReportStatus of Legislative Policy Division submitting report relative to Risk Management in the City of Detroit. (Risk Management is a critical function of government. In the FY 2015 CAFR the City reported a total of $152.6 million in long-term obligations for workers compensation, legal (claims and judgments), disability benefits, and vehicular liabilities for both Governmental and Business-type activities. This was an $11.7 million increase from the $140.9 million for FY 2014. The City has a large exposure to claims and judgments for personal injury and property damage. City services such as transportation, street and sidewalk maintenance, police and fire that if not properly developed, maintained and managed could result in accidents and other incidents that the City could be liable for.) (BROUGHT BACK AS DIRECTED ON 9-7-16)   Not available
15-4063 1  ContractSubmitting reso. autho. Contract No. 6000267 - 100% City Funding - To Provide Diesel Exhaust Fluid - Contractor: Corrigan Oil Company, Location: 775 N. 2nd Street, Brighton, MI 48116 - Contract Period: October 1, 2016 through September 30, 2017 - Total Contract Amount: $107,000.00. CITYWIDE (REFERRED TO THE BUDGET, FINANCE AND AUDIT STANDING COMMITTEE ON 9-21-16)   Not available
15-4064 1  AppointmentSubmitting report relative to Whether the Chief Financial Officer is Properly Involved in the Selection of the Auditing Firm to Prepare the City’s Comprehensive Annual Financial Report (CAFR); whether such Involvement by the CFO is Consistent with the Detroit City Charter. (There is no conflict of interest. While the Charter is silent as it relates to the CAFR, state law is not. Under Uniform Budgeting and Accounting Act and the Home Rule City Act, the City’s Chief Financial Officer (“CFO”), with oversight by the Financial Review Commission, has the specific authority to create and maintain the CAFR for the City of Detroit.) (REFERRED TO THE BUDGET, FINANCE AND AUDIT STANDING COMMITTEE ON 9-21-16)   Not available
15-4065 1  Communication or ReportSubmitting report relative to Report on Gaming Tax Revenue through August 2016. (For the eleventh year, MGM and Motor City are projected to exceed $400 million in the calendar year and increase gaming tax collections by $10.46 million between September and December. MGM reached $400 million in early September and Motor City is projected to reach $400 million in mid-November.) (REFERRED TO THE BUDGET, FINANCE AND AUDIT STANDING COMMITTEE ON 9-21-16)   Not available
15-4066 1  AppointmentSubmitting report relative to CAFR Auditor Selection. (This contract under review is to audit the FY 2016 - 2019 CAFRs. While it does not appear that Plante & Moran PLLC is technically in conflict of interest, it is clear the auditor selection process was tainted by participation in the selection process by the Office of the Chief Financial Officer members responsible for the preparation of the City’s financial statements to be audited. The Legislative Policy Division recommends that the Inspector General review the auditor selection process to determine any improprieties and ethics violations.) (REFERRED TO THE BUDGET, FINANCE AND AUDIT STANDING COMMITTEE ON 9-21-16)   Not available